Elusive Memories

I was walking up Forbes Avenue, somewhere between Morewood and Beeler, when a memory implanted itself in my mind. I was with my friend Sam, so I was either a freshman or early sophomore (our friendship faded out winter break of sophomore year), and it was cold. I imagine we were going to a party, though I can’t understand why we were walking on that side of the street–the side near the parking garage–if that was the case. Maybe we were headed somewhere to pregame first?

We were walking up Forbes and suddenly I remembered a thing so vividly and intensely. I remember being amused. I remember being really confused. Why had I not remembered this thing for so long, and then suddenly it was vividly there?

I told Sam about the memory that had come up. I imagine it was inspired by something she must have been telling me. I remember telling her the memory and her saying “why hadn’t you ever told me that before?” And I remember saying “Because I didn’t remember it before.”

I’m not avoiding telling you this sudden magical memory, by the way. I honestly can’t remember it. It was something that came back to me briefly. And though I have this strange memory of remembering this thing, I can’t remember what that thing actually is. Or was?

Having now studied psychology I have a slightly better (but by no means comprehensive) understanding of memory. I understand highly emotional memories are burned most strongly in our brain. I understand that with each retelling, each accessing of a memory if you will, it is slightly altered. Remembered a little bit differently. I understand that the easiest memories to access are the ones that have many connections to them. That’s why a lot of times when I can’t remember a word or answer, I’ll try accessing it in a different route. I’ll remember that it once reminded me of something else and go that direction. I understand that memories that are not accessed often are harder to recall, if only because those pathways are pretty wonky. They’re the dirt roads to the freshly repaved highways of the recently remembered.

I think back to this story about once a year because it is such a mystery. I remember so strongly the feeling of awe when I remembered whatever memory popped into my brain during that walk. I remember thinking that things suddenly made sense. Not big things. Not my whole life. But some things. I remember that flash of memory, for a second, made the roadmap of my life a little clearer.

Memory is elusive and confusing and not at all precise or scientific. And yet it is fascinating. In the process of writing about myself, of starting, and stopping, and wishing, and hoping and blushing about my desire to eventually one day write a memoir and/or a family history, a lot of things come up. It’s random, and if I don’t write them down quickly–a note on my phone, a phrase in my journal–there’s a good chance I won’t remember.

A few weeks ago at work during a therapy group, the therapist asked our clients to write a story about their past. It didn’t have to relate to why they were in treatment, just a story. A lot of the clients balked. They didn’t want to go there. They didn’t want to think about their families or their friends or any step in what led them to be where they were. I wanted to tell them how therapeutic writing had become for me. How the first pieces of memoir I wrote that I was truly proud of suddenly made sense of a life that had seemed so painfully meaningless before, so chaotic.

But I also recognized that that only happened well into my adulthood. When I was ready for it to happen. Seemingly out of nowhere. This story spilled out of me that fit so perfectly together, that had motifs and themes without my trying, that I was left wondering how I had never noticed those patterns before.

The thing with memory is you get to go into your past, with the knowledge and wisdom of time and age. And without those things, memories are often just painful retellings. With those things, memories, to me, become genius.

Eleven

**I wrote this piece about nine months ago in an intro to non-fiction writing class. It was the first piece I ever wrote that made me think I might want to be a writer. It is one of my many stories.

You are eleven and you are writing down everything you ate in the last week in the small notebook you got from the LA Weight Loss lady. She is blonde with too-big hair and blue eyeshadow, but she’s not fat and that’s all you aspire to be. You write what you’ve eaten, knowing that afterwards you and your mom will go to Boston Market and get a quarter of a chicken with green beans and new potatoes, and peel the skin off because that’s what LA Weight Loss tells you you should do. You write what you’ve eaten, knowing that after the lady weighs you and your mom in, if you haven’t lost enough weight or if, god forbid, you gained weight she’ll ask you if you had a bowel movement that day or if maybe you’re near that time of the month. You learn not to be too embarrassed or ashamed by these questions because if your bowel hasn’t moved in a few days or you are supposed to start your period soon then the weight gain is not your fault. It doesn’t even cross your mind that the weight gain might be an indicator that the diet outlined by LA Weight Loss doesn’t work. After all you are eleven, and this is only your first diet.

You are eleven and a boy likes you. Or so your friend says. She’s not exactly your friend. She’s actually a friend of a friend who rides to school with you even though you go to Merriam and she goes to McCarthy. But you do get to spend recess together, and that’s when you find out about the boy. It’s not the boy you’re really in love with with the dreamy hair and the nonchalant attitude. It’s his goofy best friend, the clown of the class. He’s literally chinless. He’s kind of like a cartoon. He’s got big teeth and a small bump where there should be a clear separation between his face and his neck. He’s not just skinny, but lanky, like gravity is really doing a number on his limbs. His hair sticks out in all directions mainly because, unlike the other upper-echelon boys in the class, he doesn’t wear a hat. When your friend who is not exactly your friend tells you this boy likes you, you blush and smile privately because you know how you make each other laugh. But that moment barely lasts a single second before it dawns on you that there is no way any boy, let alone a boy in the upper echelon of your class, could like a girl like you, a chubby girl.

You are eleven, and that day you go home and tell your mom that you need to go on a diet. Years later your mom will tell you that her stomach sank when you said those words, that she never wanted you to go down this path. But going on a diet doesn’t only seem essential for the sake of any real possible relationship with this boy, it also seems like a rite of passage into womanhood to eleven year old you. You go to your pediatrician to get her to sign off on your diet, because no respectable diet program would allow an eleven year old to go on a diet…without a doctor’s approval. Your doctor approves as she’s been hounding you to lose weight since she met you six months ago, I mean you are a little high on the BMI scale. You don’t know what that means, but you know that it’s bad, and you know that it’s related to the fact that you’re fat. Your doctor is hopeful that maybe you’ll hit a growth spurt, and everything will even out, but a diet is a good idea anyway.

You are eleven, and you don’t yet know that in fifteen years you will still know the BMI cutoff for “normal” weight even though you’ll try your best to forget it.

You are eleven, and you don’t yet know that the only time you will be “normal” according to BMI will be the summer between your freshman and sophomore year of college. When you’ll religiously eat between 600 and 800 calories a day, workout for thirty minutes every morning, and spend most afternoons reading in bed because you’re just too tired to do anything else.

You are eleven, and this is your very first diet, and you are excited and hopeful because “diet” means “thin” and “thin” means “everything will be ok.”

You are eleven and you don’t yet know that you will continue to try different diets with different rates of success for the next fifteen years. You don’t yet know that 95% of dieters gain the weight back and more. And even if you did, you don’t yet know that it is not the fault of those dieters. That their inability to keep the weight off is not a reflection of their weak character or lack of self-control, but of bodies working overtime to keep them alive. You don’t yet know that dieting is one of the most powerful triggers of eating disorders that we know of today. And that in the fifteen years after your first diet you will present with symptoms of anorexia nervosa, anorexia athletica, binge eating disorder, body dysmorphic disorder, and orthorexia. You don’t yet know how often eating disorders are not diagnosed in fat women, and that, worse yet, eating disorder behaviors are often prescribed to fat women. You don’t yet know that in fifteen years you will consider yourself lucky for having gotten out in your twenties and not in your forties or sixties or never.